On May 8, 2025, white smoke rose from the Sistine Chapel, signalling the election of Cardinal Robert Francis Prevost as Pope Leo XIV, the first American-born pontiff in the Catholic Church’s 2,000-year history. This historic moment marks a significant shift for the global institution, as the 69-year-old Augustinian friar brings a unique blend of American roots, Latin American experience, and Vatican insider expertise to the papacy. As the 267th successor to St. Peter, Pope Leo XIV’s background, views, and priorities offer clues about the future direction of the Catholic Church in a polarised world grappling with social, environmental, and spiritual challenges.
A Chicago Native with a Global Perspective
Born in 1955 in Chicago, Illinois, Robert Prevost grew up in a devout Catholic family of French, Italian, and Spanish immigrant descent in the south suburban town of Dolton. His parents were deeply involved in their parish, with his mother active in the Altar & Rosary Society and his father serving as a lector. This environment nurtured Prevost’s faith from an early age, and he served as an altar boy before pursuing a vocation with the Augustinian order.
Prevost’s academic journey took him to Villanova University in Pennsylvania, where he earned a degree in mathematics, followed by theological studies at the Catholic Theological Union in Chicago, where he obtained a Master’s of Divinity. Ordained a priest in 1982, he was sent to Peru in 1985, beginning a decades-long ministry that would shape his worldview and pastoral approach. In Peru, he worked as a missionary, serving marginalised communities in Trujillo and later as Bishop and Archbishop of Chiclayo from 2014 to 2023. He became a Peruvian citizen in 2015, cementing his deep ties to Latin America.
In 2023, Pope Francis called Prevost to Rome, appointing him prefect of the Dicastery for Bishops, a powerful role overseeing the selection of bishops worldwide, and president of the Pontifical Commission for Latin America. Francis made him a cardinal in 2023, and in early 2025, elevated him to the highest rank of cardinals, signalling his trust in Prevost as a potential successor. This rapid rise reflects Prevost’s reputation as a steady, reform-minded leader with a global outlook.
Views: Continuity with Francis, with a Centrist Touch
Pope Leo XIV is widely seen as a continuity candidate, aligning with the reformist spirit of Pope Francis, particularly on issues like social justice, environmental stewardship, and outreach to the marginalised. However, his approach is described as centrist, balancing progressive social priorities with traditional doctrinal stances, which may shape his papacy’s tone and priorities.
Social Justice and the Environment
Prevost shares Francis’s emphasis on the poor, migrants, and environmental care. His years in Peru, working with underserved communities, instilled a deep concern for economic inequality and social exclusion. In a 2020 tweet, he called for Church leaders to “reject racism and seek justice,” signalling a commitment to addressing systemic inequalities. On climate change, he has echoed Francis’s urgency, advocating for a shift “from words to action” and a “relationship of reciprocity” with the environment. He has highlighted Vatican initiatives like solar panels and electric vehicles as steps toward sustainability.
His choice of the name Leo XIV is significant, evoking Pope Leo XIII (1878–1903), whose encyclical Rerum Novarum laid the foundation for Catholic social justice teachings, addressing workers’ rights and economic fairness during the Industrial Revolution. Observers see this as a signal that Leo XIV intends to prioritise social justice in a world facing economic disparities, migration crises, and climate challenges.
Church Reform and Synodality
Prevost has embraced Francis’s vision of a “synodal” Church—one that listens, dialogues, and involves the laity in decision-making. In his first address from St. Peter’s Basilica, he called for a “missionary Church” that “builds bridges” and engages in “dialogue with love,” emphasising unity and outreach. As prefect of the Dicastery for Bishops, he supported Francis’s revolutionary reform of including three women in the voting bloc for bishop nominations, praising their contributions as an “enrichment” to the discernment process. This suggests he will continue to expand women’s roles in Church governance, though he has opposed ordaining women as deacons, indicating a conservative stance on sacramental roles.
Social Issues and Doctrine
On contentious social issues, Prevost appears to tread a middle path. He has supported Francis’s 2023 declaration allowing blessings for same-sex couples and those in “irregular situations,” but emphasised that such blessings must be interpreted within local cultural contexts. This nuanced stance suggests openness to pastoral flexibility without altering Church doctrine, which remains traditional on issues like marriage and sexuality. His views on LGBTQ+ inclusion are less explicit than Francis’s, leading some conservative groups to speculate he may be less welcoming, though no clear evidence supports this.
Prevost’s tenure in Peru was not without controversy, as allegations surfaced that he covered up sexual abuse claims, which his diocese denied. The Survivors Network of those Abused by Priests (SNAP) urged the new pope to prioritise justice for abuse victims, reflecting ongoing pressure to address the Church’s abuse crisis decisively. How Leo XIV responds to this issue will be a critical test of his leadership.
Geopolitical Engagement
As an American pope with Latin American ties, Leo XIV is uniquely positioned to navigate global tensions. His election breaks the informal taboo against a U.S. pope, previously seen as risky due to America’s geopolitical dominance. His Peruvian citizenship and ministry experience may have eased concerns among cardinals, presenting him as a bridge between the Global North and South. Observers note his diplomatic sensitivity, honed in Vatican roles, will be crucial in addressing issues like migration, religious freedom, and conflicts in Ukraine, the Middle East, and Sudan.
His relationship with the U.S. political landscape, particularly the Trump administration, will be closely watched. Francis’s 2025 letter rebuking Trump’s mass deportation plans highlighted Vatican concerns about the politicisation of Christianity. Prevost’s American background may equip him to engage U.S. politics with nuance, though his call for “peace” and “dialogue” suggests a preference for moral guidance over direct confrontation.
What This Means for the Future of the Church
Pope Leo XIV’s papacy signals both continuity and evolution for the Catholic Church. His alignment with Francis’s priorities—synodality, social justice, and environmental care—suggests the Church will continue its outward focus, engaging a world marked by division and despair. The choice of a non-European pope, following Francis’s Latin American papacy, underscores the Church’s growing embrace of its global constituency, particularly in the Global South, where Catholicism is expanding rapidly.
A Unifying Voice in a Polarised World
At 69, Leo XIV could have a long pontificate, potentially spanning a decade or more. His call for a Church that “builds bridges” and his emphasis on peace position him as a unifying figure amid global polarisation. His multicultural background—American-born, Peruvian citizen, Vatican veteran—equips him to address the diverse needs of 1.4 billion Catholics. However, he faces the challenge of healing internal Church divisions, particularly between progressive and conservative factions, exacerbated by Francis’s reforms. His centrist approach may help, but navigating issues like women’s roles, LGBTQ+ inclusion, and abuse scandals will require deft leadership.
Strengthening the Global South
Prevost’s Latin American experience aligns with the Church’s demographic shift toward Africa, Asia, and South America, where membership is growing. His election reflects Francis’s legacy of diversifying the College of Cardinals, with 80% of the 2025 conclave’s voters appointed by him. Leo XIV is likely to prioritise the Global South’s concerns, such as poverty, climate change, and debt crises, as highlighted by Christine Allen of the Catholic Agency for Overseas Development. This focus could enhance the Church’s relevance in regions where it is thriving, while addressing declining membership in Europe and North America.
Addressing the Abuse Crisis
The shadow of the clergy abuse scandal looms large. SNAP’s open letter to the new pope underscores the urgency of delivering justice to survivors, criticising past complicity by cardinals and popes. Leo XIV’s response to these demands will define his moral authority. His Peruvian diocese’s denial of cover-up allegations suggests a defensive posture, but his Vatican role overseeing bishop selections indicates familiarity with the need for accountability. A proactive approach—perhaps adopting Cardinal Anders Arborelius’s idea of a papal advisory cabinet—could strengthen governance and restore trust.
A Steady Hand with a Social Justice Core
Unlike Francis, known for his spontaneity, Leo XIV is described as a “mild-mannered” leader offering a “steadier hand” at the Vatican’s helm. His low profile on controversial issues may allow him to avoid the lightning-rod status Francis occasionally attracted, particularly from U.S. conservatives who criticised Francis’s Argentine perspective. Yet, his commitment to social justice, inspired by Leo XIII, suggests he will not shy away from addressing systemic issues like poverty, migration, and climate change, potentially challenging political powers, including in the U.S.
Conclusion
Pope Leo XIV’s election as the first American pope is a historic milestone, reflecting the Catholic Church’s global evolution. His background—rooted in Chicago, shaped by Peru, and refined in the Vatican—positions him as a bridge-builder in a fractured world. His views, blending Francis’s reformist spirit with a centrist doctrinal stance, suggest a papacy focused on unity, social justice, and environmental stewardship, while cautiously navigating divisive issues like LGBTQ+ inclusion and women’s roles.
For the future, Leo XIV faces the daunting task of leading 1.4 billion Catholics through geopolitical tensions, internal divisions, and the ongoing abuse crisis. His call for a “missionary Church” that “walks together” signals an inclusive vision, but translating this into action will test his diplomatic and pastoral skills. As he steps into this role, the world watches to see how this Augustinian friar, with a heart for the poor and a mind for reform, will shape the Catholic Church’s path forward.